Skip to main content

Table 1 The present case and 17 reported surgical cases of recurrent IPNB [10, 12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19,20,21,22,23,24,25,26,27]

From: Recurrent intraductal papillary neoplasm of the bile duct due to intraductal dissemination: a case report and literature review

  Primary lesion Recurrence lesion  
References Year Primary surgery Resection margin Pathological type Second treatment Pathological type Location of Primary lesion Location of Recurrence lesion Recurrence below the primary tumor Mucin production (Primary/Recurrence) Conversion from non-invasive type to invasive type Recurrence after the second surgery (months)
[13] 1996 Lt. hepatectomy Not listed Not listed Not listed Not listed IHBD CBD Yes Not listed Not listed Not lised
[14] 2005 Lt. hepatectomy Not listed Not listed Anterior segmentectomy/ extrahepatic bile duct resection Not listed LHD CBD Yes Yes/Yes Not listed Not lited
[15] 2006 Extrahepatic bile duct resection Negative Not listed PD Not listed Upper CBD Lower CBD Yes Not listed Yes 12
[16] 2007 Cholecystectomy Negative Not listed PD Not listed Cystic duct Lower CBD Yes Yes/Yes No No recurrence
[17] 2008 PD Not listed Not listed Rt. hepatectomy Not listed Lower CBD RHD No Not listed Not listed 24
[18] 2009 Lt. hepatectomy/cadate lobectomy Negative Not listed Tumor enucleation Not listed B4 CBD Yes Yes/Yes No 28
[19] 2010 Lt. hepatectomy/caudate lobectomy/gall bladder resection Not listed Not listed PD Not listed LHD CBD Yes Not listed Not listed No recurrence
[20] 2013 Lt. hepatectomy/caudate lobectomy/extrahepatic bile duct resection Negative Not listed PD Not listed LHD CBD Yes Not listed No No recurrence
[21] 2013 Cholecystectomy Not listed Gastric Resected(details unknown) Gastric Gall bladder Lower CBD Yes Not listed No Not listed
[22] 2014 Lt. hepatectomy Negative Not listed extrahepatic bile duct resection Not listed B2 CBD Yes Yes/Yes Yes 35
[23] 2015 Rt. hepatectomy/caudate lobectomy/extrahepatic bile duct resection Negative Intestinal PD Intestinal RHD CBD Yes Yes/Yes No No recurrence
[10] 2015 Lt. hepatectomy/caudate lobectomy/extrahepatic bile duct resection Negative Pancreaticobiliary stent detention Pancreaticobiliary LHD RHD No Not listed Not listed
[12] 2016 Rt. Hepatectomy Positive Intestinal PD Intestinal RHD CBD Yes Yes/Yes No No recurrence
[24] 2018 Lt. hepatectomy/caudate lobectomy/extrahepatic bile duct resection Negative Not listed stent detention Not listed LHD-CBD B5 No Not listed Not listed
[25] 2019 Lt. hepatectomy No listed Not listed Not listed Not listed LHD RHD No Not listed Not listed Not listed
[26] 2019 Extrahepatic bile duct resection Negative Not listed Not listed Not listed CBD Lower CBD Yes Not listed Not listed Not listed
[27] 2020 Rt. hepatectomy/caudate lobectomy/extrahepatic bile duct resection Negative Pancreaticobiliary PD Pancreaticobiliary RHD CBD Yes No/No Not listed No recurrence
Our case 2020 Lt. trisectionectomy Negative Gastric PD Gastric LHD CBD Yes Yes/Yes Yes 19
  1. IHBD intrahepatic bile duct, LHD left hepatic duct, RHD right hepatic duct, CBD common bile duct, PD pancreaticoduodenectomy, Lt. Left, Rt. right, B2 Bile duct to liver segment 2, B4 Bile duct to liver segment 4, B5 Bile duct to liver segment 5