Skip to main content

Table.1 List of previously reported cases with right-sided Bochdalek hernia in adults

From: Right-sided Bochdalek hernia in an adult with hepatic malformation and intestinal malrotation

Author

Year

Age

Sex

Chief complain

Anomaly

Herniated viscera

Size of defect

Route

Approach

Sac

Repair

Sato

1973

48

M

Chest pain, dyspnea

Visceral inversion

Mesenterium commune

Jejunum, ileum

6 × 3 cm

A

Laparotomic

Unknown

Suture

Ochi

1984

43

M

Abdominal pain, abdominal distension

Gastric volvulus

Duodenum, liver, gallbladder

Chicken egg size

T/A

Thoracotomic

Laparotomic

Absent

Suture

Zaima

1984

47

F

Chest pain

Mesenterium commune

Thinning of the right hepatic lobe

Small intestine, colon

6 × 4 cm

A

Laparotomic

Absent

Suture

Sinha

1989

70

F

Chest pain, shortness of breath

None

Colon

3 × 3 cm

A

Laparotomic

Unknown

Suture

Idota

1997

68

F

Abdominal pain

Thinning of the liver

Incomplete fixation of the colon

Ileum, colon

8 × 5 cm

A

Laparotomic

Absent

Suture

Mar Fan

1999

36

F

Abdominal pain

None

Small intestine

5 cm

A

Laparotomic

Absent

Suture

Zenda

2000

69

M

Abdominal pain

Thinning of the liver

Ileum, colon, gallbladder

15 × 10 cm

A

Laparotomic

Unknown

Suture

Kanazawa

2002

63

F

Abdominal pain, dyspnea

Thinning of the liver

Colon, kidney

12 cm

T/A

Thoracotomic

Laparotomic

Unknown

Suture

Kiriyama

2002

41

F

Cough, sputum

Thinning of the liver

Intestinal malrotation

Stomach, duodenum, small intestine

10 × 7 cm

A

Laparotomic

Absent

Mesh

Masuda

2007

80

F

Abdominal pain, vomiting

Incomplete fixation of the duodenum

Stomach, duodenum

Unknown

A

Laparotomic

Unknown

Suture

Rosen

2007

50

M

Dyspnea

None

Retroperitoneal fat

2 × 2 cm

A

Laparoscopic

Unknown

Mesh

Hirose

2008

64

M

Cough, hemoptysis

None

Colon, liver, kidney

8 × 8 cm

T

Thoracotomic

Absent

Mesh

Fraser

2009

75

F

Cough

None

Small intestine, colon, kidney

8 × 5 cm

T/A

Thoracoscopic

Laparoscopic

Present

Mesh

Laakesonen

2009

38

F

Abdominal pain

None

Colon, liver

10 cm

T/A

Thoracotomic

Laparoscopic

Absent

Suture + mesh

Matsushita

2009

21

F

No complaint

None

Small part of the liver

3 cm

T/A

Thoracotomic

Laparotomic

Present

Suture

Murakami

2010

85

M

Abdominal pain

Thinning of the liver

Ileum

3 cm

A

Laparotomic

Absent

Mesh

Nishiwaki

2011

59

M

Dyspnea

None

Small intestine, liver

10 × 8 cm

T

Thoracotomic

Absent

Mesh

Choi

2012

29

M

Chest pain, dyspnea

Thinning of the liver

Duodenum, ileum, jejunum, colon, pancreas head

7 cm

T/A

Thoracotomic

Laparotomic

Unknown

Mesh

Almeida

2013

49

F

Cough, sputum

None

Colon

6 × 3 cm

A

Laparotomic

Absent

Suture

Miyake

2013

80

M

Abdominal pain

Unknown

Small intestine

Unknown

A

Laparotomic

Unknown

Suture

Mizoguchi

2013

71

F

Dyspnea

Mesenterium commune

Small intestine, colon

4 × 3.5 cm

A

Laparotomic

Absent

Mesh

Patle

2013

50

F

Dyspnea, abdominal discomfort

Incomplete fixation of the liver

Colon, kidney

10 × 8 cm

A

Laparoscopic

Absent

Suture + mesh

Debergh

2014

38

F

Abdominal pain

None

Small intestine

5 × 4 cm

A

Laparoscopic

Absent

Suture

Salústio

2014

50

F

Abdominal pain, vomiting

Intestinal malrotation

Incomplete fixation of the colon and the liver

Small intestine

Unknown

A

Laparotomic

Unknown

Suture

Watanabe

2015

65

F

Abdominal pain, dyspnea

None

Colon, small part of the liver

5 cm

A

Laparotomic

Absent

Suture

Kohli

2016

22

M

Chest pain, shortness of breath

Abnormal rotation of the liver

Small intestine, colon, gallbladder

10 cm

T/A

Thoracotomic

Laparoscopic

Present

Mesh

Ohtsuka

2016

89

F

Abdominal pain, vomiting, dyspnea

Incomplete fixation of the colon

Ileum, colon

4.5 × 3 cm

A

Laparotomic

Absent

Suture

Moro

2017

89

F

Abdominal pain

None

Ileum

3 × 2 cm

A

Laparotomic

Unknown

Suture

Jambhekar

2018

74

M

Nausea, vomiting

None

Colon, liver

8 × 6 cm

A

Robotic

Unknown

Suture

Hojo

2019

70

F

Abdominal pain

Thinning of the liver incomplete fixation of the colon

Ileum, colon, liver

6 × 5 cm

A

Laparoscopic

Absent

Suture

Toda

2019

72

M

Nausea

None

Retroperitoneal fat

8 × 5 cm

T

Thoracotomic

Absent

Suture

Onishi

2020

66

F

Abdominal pain

Thinning of the liver

Colon, liver, gallbladder

7 × 5 cm

T/A

Thoracoscopic

Laparoscopic

Absent

Suture

Kyoku

2021

77

F

Abdominal pain

None

Small intestine

3 × 3 cm

A

Laparotomic

Absent

Suture

Present case

2021

47

F

Dyspnea

Thinning of the liver

Intestinal malrotation

Duodenum, small intestine, colon, kidney

11 × 5 cm

A

Laparotomic

Absent

Mesh

  1. A Abdominal, F Female, M Male, T Thoracic, T/A Thoracoabdominal