Skip to main content

Table 1 Literature review: salvage surgery after dCRT with high-dose radiation

From: Salvage surgery after definitive chemoradiotherapy through VATS for an initial unresectable locally advanced lung cancer: an alternative consolidative modality to radiotherapy?

Author

/(published year /patient no.)

Yu et al. (2021/1)

Bauman (2008/24)

Kuzmik (2013/14)

Yang

(2015/31)

Schreiner

(2016/9)

Casiraghi

(2017/35)

Romero

(2019/27)

Bograd

(2020/30)

Age (y/o)a

73

60

64

58

56.2

60–69

65.1

65.5

PreOP stagingb

IIIB

IIIA

III

IIIA

IIIA

IIIA

IIIA/B

IIIA

Smoking historyb

Former

N/A

N/A

Former

N/A

N/A

N/A

Former

Histologyb

SqCC

NSCLC

NSCLC

NSCLC

NSCLC

NSCLC/SCLC

NSCLC

SqCC

Radiotherapy dose (cGy)a

9000

6390

5700

6000

6620

Mean 5800

6500

6000

dCRT to salvage OP (days)

164 (980)

147a

N/A

123.9a

211.4a

210a

250.6a

279ǂ

Pre-operative FEV1 (L)

2.33

2.3a

1.9a

69%c

N/A

N/A

N/A

N/A

Initially inoperable (No.)

1

8

2

8

1

14

12

8

Resection extent (Extended %)

Nil

20.8

28.6

19.4

78

45

N/A

37

Sublobar

3

1

Lobectomy

10

8

30

6

11

7

6

Bilobectomy

1

4

1

1

1

7

Sleeve lobectomy

1

Pneumonectomy

10

2

-

1

17

14

5

Exploratory only

6

Approach (open/VATS)

VATS

Open

Open

Openb

Openb

Open

Open

Open

Operating time (hour)a

6.5

5.5

N/A

N/A

3.9

N/A

N/A

4.9

Estimated blood loss (ml)a

50

250

N/A

N/A

400

N/A

N/A

150

Morbidity/mortality (%)

0

58.3(4.2)

43(0)

48(0)

22(11)

51(5.7)

14.8(3.7)

57(6.7)

Hospital stay after OP (days)a

8

8

10

4

20

7

8

7

Survival (months)a

42(7d)

3d

9d

32.5d

23d

13

75.6

24

  1. SqCC squamous cell carcinoma, ADC adenocarcinoma, N/A not available, SCLC small-cell lung cancer
  2. aPresented as median number
  3. bRepresented by the majority of patients included
  4. cPresented as mean number
  5. dPostoperatively