Table 1 Literature review of paracecal hernia cases from 1980 to 2019
From: Paracecal hernia due to membranous adhesion of the omentum to the right paracolic gutter
No. | Authors | Reference | Year | Age | Sex | History of abdominal surgery | Meyer’s classification | Orifice | Surgical approach | Resection of bowel | Treatment of the hernia orifice |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Rosen | [6] | 1982 | 80 | F | None | Retrocecal recess type | Retrocecal recess | Laparotomy | – | Closure |
2 | Rivkind | [3] | 1986 | 0 | F | NA | Lateral type | Paracolic sulci | Laparotomy | – | NA |
3 | Rivkind | [3] | 1986 | 8 | M | NA | Lateral type | Paracolic sulci | Laparotomy | – | Open |
4 | Rivkind | [3] | 1986 | 25 | M | NA | Lateral type | Paracolic sulci | Laparotomy | – | NA |
5 | Rivkind | [3] | 1986 | 77 | F | NA | Lateral type | Paracolic sulci | Laparotomy | – | NA |
6 | Rivkind | [3] | 1986 | 83 | F | NA | Lateral type | Paracolic sulci | Laparotomy | – | Closure |
7 | Lindsey | [7] | 1997 | 86 | F | NA | Retrocecal recess type | Retrocecal recess | Laparoscopy | – | Open |
8 | Patterson | [8] | 2000 | 59 | M | None | Lateral type | Paracolic sulci | Laparotomy | – | NA |
9 | Lu | [9] | 2002 | 69 | M | None | NA | NA | Laparotomy | – | NA |
10 | Lu | [9] | 2002 | 67 | F | Appendectomy | NA | NA | Laparotomy | – | NA |
11 | Omori | [10] | 2003 | 90 | F | None | NA | NA | Laparoscopy | – | Closure |
12 | Osadchy | [1] | 2005 | 76 | M | None | Lateral type | Paracolic sulci | Laparotomy | – | Closure |
13 | Fu | [11] | 2006 | 34 | M | None | Internal type | Inferior ileocecal recess | Laparotomy | – | Closure |
14 | Molto Aguado | [12] | 2007 | 59 | F | None | Lateral type | Paracolic sulci | Laparotomy | + | Closure |
15 | Hirokawa | [13] | 2007 | 74 | M | Appendectomy | Retrocecal recess type | Retrocecal recess | Laparoscopy-assisted | – | Open |
16 | Kabashima | [14] | 2010 | 43 | F | Invagination | Lateral type | Paracolic sulci | Laparoscopy | – | Open |
17 | Shibuya | [15] | 2010 | 63 | M | NA | Retrocecal recess type | Retrocecal recess | Laparotomy | – | Closure |
18 | Choh | [16] | 2010 | 65 | F | None | NA | NA | Laparotomy | + | Closure |
19 | Jang | [17] | 2011 | 84 | F | None | Lateral type | Paracolic sulci | Laparotomy | – | Open |
20 | Nishi | [18] | 2011 | 70 | F | None | Lateral type | Paracolic sulci | Laparotomy | – | Open |
21 | Kleyman | [19] | 2013 | 34 | F | None | NA | NA | Laparotomy | – | Closure |
22 | Saygin | [20] | 2015 | 50 | F | None | Lateral type | Paracolic sulci | Laparoscopy | – | NA |
23 | Kumar | [21] | 2015 | 88 | F | None | Internal type | Inferior ileocecal recess | Laparotomy | + | Ileocecal resection |
24 | Sasaki | [22] | 2016 | 65 | M | None | Retrocecal recess type | Retrocecal recess | Laparoscopy | – | Closure |
25 | Ogami | [23] | 2016 | 92 | M | Cholecystectomy | Retrocecal recess type | Retrocecal recess | Laparoscopy | – | Open |
26 | Ito | [24] | 2017 | 83 | M | None | Retrocecal recess type | Retrocecal recess | Laparotomy | – | Open |
27 | Chia | [25] | 2017 | 32 | M | None | Retrocecal recess type | Retrocecal recess | Laparoscopy | – | Open |
28 | Tayaran | [26] | 2017 | 75 | F | None | Lateral type | Paracolic sulci | Laparoscopy | – | Closure |
29 | Inukai | [27] | 2018 | 54 | M | None | Lateral type | Paracolic sulci | Laparoscopy-assisted | + | Open |
30 | Menezes | [28] | 2018 | 40 | M | None | NA | NA | Laparotomy | – | Open |
31 | Otani | [29] | 2018 | 83 | F | None | Lateral type | Paracolic sulci | Laparoscopy | – | Open |
32 | Aljaberi | [30] | 2019 | 16 | M | None | Internal type | Superior ileocolic recess | Laparotomy converted from laparoscopy | + | Ileocecal resection |
33 | Present case |  | 2019 | 86 | F | Appendectomy | Lateral type | Membranous adhesion of the omentum | Laparotomy | – | Open |